"April Mașini answers
questions no one else can
and tells you the truth
that no one else will."

I Bee-Lieve

4 dates in and im getting mixed messages

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 16 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #6131
    WickedTrombone
    Member #228,695

    Backstory: We met through an online dating site. We’ve been on 4 dates in the past month. The first 3 dates were a little bit of fun and romantic. We are definitely attracted to eachother. The furthest we had gone intimacy wise was kissing / hugging on the 3rd date. On the fourth date, things got really hot and heavy. She climbed ontop of me in her bed and started kissing my neck, biting my ear, tugging on my boxers, really pressing her hips into me. It was an intense makeout session. She stopped me when I began kissing her chest, saying she thought we were going too fast from where we last left off, considering the most we had done was just kiss on the last date. I said fine, you’re right.

    Was she testing me here? Did she want me to push the envelope? (Adding onto this, a week or two prior to the incident she texted me saying she was going to bed, I jokingly said I’ll come with her. She said you’d drive down here right now? I said maybe someday but not tonight. She said ‘Aww you got my hopes up =[‘

    Moving on, a few days later she texts me at 2AM saying she had a crappy night. I sent a few funny texts her way to cheer her up, which I think worked due to her sending back smiley faces. I said I was going to bed because I had work in the morning and she told me she hopes I sleep well. That was the last time I heard from her for 48 hours. I texted her the next day, never got a response. A day later, I decided to call and it went to voicemail. I left a message stating I wanted to see her again on Wednesday and to get back to me.

    She got back to me alright, 8 hours later. She sent me a text just saying ‘Hey!’ and I said Hi. She asked ‘How are you?’ I said I was doing well, what have you been up to? And we’re silent again.

    I’m not really sure what to make of this girl. Is she playing hard to get? Mind games? is she just inconsiderate? I’m at the point where I am purposely putting off texting her if she responds to me, just to make her wait like I do.

    #26971
    Ask April Masini
    Keymaster

    From what you’ve written it sounds like she likes you, but you dropped the ball. 😮 When you left her a message saying you wanted to see her on Wednesday, she responded — but then you didn’t ask her out on a date. That sent her the message that you lost interest. If you want to date her, ask her out! 😉 She sounds like she’d say yes again.

    [b]Everyone likes to be liked! If the advice you found on AskApril.com was helpful “like” us on FB — and tell a friend!
    [url][/url]

    And… you can follow my interviews and advice in the press on Twitter [i]@AskAprilcom[/i][/b]

    #26901
    WickedTrombone
    Member #228,695

    [quote=”April Masini”]From what you’ve written it sounds like she likes you, but you dropped the ball. 😮 When you left her a message saying you wanted to see her on Wednesday, she responded — but then you didn’t ask her out on a date. That sent her the message that you lost interest. If you want to date her, ask her out! 😉 She sounds like she’d say yes again.

    [b]Everyone likes to be liked! If the advice you found on AskApril.com was helpful “like” us on FB — and tell a friend!
    [url][/url]

    And… you can follow my interviews and advice in the press on Twitter [i]@AskAprilcom[/i][/b][/quote]
    Thanks for the response April. My main issue here is I don’t want to appear needy or clingy. I’ve sent the last message. She hadn’t acknowledged she even heard my voicemail in the two messages she sent me late at night. I find recently, I’m having a lot of trouble staying in contact with her consistently. I kind of feel as if she has me on the backburner.

    Should I text her once more about the Wednesday proposal, (she still hasn’t responded to my last message from last night), or should I call again? As I said, she hasn’t acknowledged my voicemail, and I do not want to appear clingy or weak. So yes, while on one hand it appears she likes me, the lack of communication throws me off.

    #26609
    Ask April Masini
    Keymaster

    You’re complicating this, and it’s simple: [i]If you want to date her, then ask her out.[/i]

    You didn’t. She lost interest. Now, you’re trying to make the absence of a date you never actually proposed to her, about other things, and it’s not. 😕

    If you want to date her, then be clear about it. Call her up and ask her out on a date on the phone because women like to hear men’s voices. 😉 If you don’t want to ask her out, then move on.

    [b]Everyone likes to be liked! If the advice you found on AskApril.com was helpful “like” us on FB — and tell a friend!
    [url][/url]

    And… you can follow my interviews and advice in the press on Twitter [i]@AskAprilcom[/i][/b]

    #26975
    WickedTrombone
    Member #228,695

    [quote=”April Masini”]You’re complicating this, and it’s simple: [i]If you want to date her, then ask her out.[/i]

    You didn’t. She lost interest. Now, you’re trying to make the absence of a date you never actually proposed to her, about other things, and it’s not. 😕

    If you want to date her, then be clear about it. Call her up and ask her out on a date on the phone because women like to hear men’s voices. 😉 If you don’t want to ask her out, then move on.

    [b]Everyone likes to be liked! If the advice you found on AskApril.com was helpful “like” us on FB — and tell a friend!
    [url][/url]

    And… you can follow my interviews and advice in the press on Twitter [i]@AskAprilcom[/i][/b][/quote]
    I did ask her. I called yesterday and left a voicemail about Wednesday and for her to get back to me. Her texting ‘hi’ and ‘how are you?’ is her getting back to me about that?

    I’ll call her once more, if I get voicemail again then what do I do here? 👿

    #26977
    Ask April Masini
    Keymaster

    Maybe I misunderstood, but here’s what I read:

    [quote]I left a message stating I wanted to see her again on Wednesday and to get back to me.

    She got back to me alright, 8 hours later. She sent me a text just saying ‘Hey!’ and I said Hi. She asked ‘How are you?’ I said I was doing well, what have you been up to? And we’re silent again.[/quote]

    I don’t see anywhere here that you asked her out on a date. 😯 You said you wanted to see her, and she called you back, but you failed to invite her to do something specific like dinner, a movie, etc.

    Did I miss something?

    #26979
    WickedTrombone
    Member #228,695

    [quote=”April Masini”]Maybe I misunderstood, but here’s what I read:

    [quote]I left a message stating I wanted to see her again on Wednesday and to get back to me.

    She got back to me alright, 8 hours later. She sent me a text just saying ‘Hey!’ and I said Hi. She asked ‘How are you?’ I said I was doing well, what have you been up to? And we’re silent again.[/quote]

    I don’t see anywhere here that you asked her out on a date. 😯 You said you wanted to see her, and she called you back, but you failed to invite her to do something specific like dinner, a movie, etc.

    Did I miss something?[/quote]
    Alright, I called again and she picked up. She sounded like she just woke up or was crying or something. Asked her if anything was wrong and she kind of hesitated like um…no everythings okay. I was going to plan something for Wednesday but I asked her if she had any plans tonight. She said no she was just laying in bed, so I said well we can do X tonight then? She said yeah. So we’re meeting in a few hours. Right after we hung up she texted me saying she’s been sick the past couple of days and feels like crap. I suppose that could be a reason for her not being very responsive.

    She’s feeling sick but she still wants to see me tonight? I don’t know if that’s good that she feels under the weather and still wants to see me, or bad because she might get me sick lol.

    #26896
    Ask April Masini
    Keymaster

    I think the lesson learned here is that it’s important to actually ask for a date and be very clear. 😉

    Have fun! 😀

    [b]Everyone likes to be liked! If the advice you found on AskApril.com was helpful “like” us on FB — and tell a friend!
    [url][/url]

    And… you can follow my interviews and advice in the press on Twitter [i]@AskAprilcom[/i][/b]

    #26793
    WickedTrombone
    Member #228,695

    Hey Amber, the date went pretty well. We had a lot of fun. She was a good sport, had a headache most of the day, she said she took some medicine to spend the day with me. By the time we got back to her place, she said her head was pounding again so I just laid in bed with her and she cuddled up against me.

    This is the 5th time we’ve seen eachother. We do NOT have much of a communication line as far as telephone goes. She’s pretty unreliable with her phone, and I’ve witnessed it firsthand while she’s with me. One of her family members even left a voicemail for her, which she let me listen to on speaker because it was funny, complaining how she never answers the phone.

    My question to you is, what’s needed to take the next step here? We haven’t had sex yet, and the closest was that fiasco I mentioned in a post earlier. We hug and kiss and hold hands but have yet to go much further. Do I somehow bring up the subject of where she thinks we’re heading? Do I keep rolling out the dates and see what happens? I fear about being the guy who keeps taking her out and paying for her (she did pay for me once which was good) and not advance in the relationship.

    Another question, we seem to be seeing eachother once a week on average. Is this a good pace? Sometimes I wish I could see her more often to speed things along while we’re still in summer.

    #23774
    Ask April Masini
    Keymaster

    [quote]My question to you is, what’s needed to take the next step here? We haven’t had sex yet, and the closest was that fiasco I mentioned in a post earlier. We hug and kiss and hold hands but have yet to go much further. Do I somehow bring up the subject of where she thinks we’re heading? Do I keep rolling out the dates and see what happens? I fear about being the guy who keeps taking her out and paying for her (she did pay for me once which was good) and not advance in the relationship.

    Another question, we seem to be seeing eachother once a week on average. Is this a good pace? Sometimes I wish I could see her more often to speed things along while we’re still in summer.[/quote]

    First of all, I recommend you buy the book I wrote for men who want to win the dating game, Date Out of Your League, so you can get more details more quickly! Here’s the link: [url]https://www.askapril.com/relationship-dating-advice/date-out-of-your-league.html[/url]. I don’t always recommend that people who post here buy a book, but in cases like yours, where you’ve posted 5 questions in 5 days — I think it’s a great idea for you. You’re looking for step by step coaching help, and this book will help you, so buy it, read it, and then let’s talk further. 😀

    That said, I’ll answer your specific questions here, now: You should NOT bring up the subject of where you’re headed, in terms of the relationship.This is going to make you appear to be insecure. 😕 Instead, you should assume that the relationship you’re in with her now is headed in the direction of [i]figuring out[/i] if this is someone you want to continue dating. After three months of dating, make that decision and either continue dating her or don’t. But don’t talk about where the relationship is headed — especially not now.

    When you talk about “rolling out the dates”, it sounds like you’re killing time, dating her, rather than figuring out by dating her if she’s someone you’re interested in and want to continue spending time with. If you’re not having fun and enjoying her company, and you’re not getting anything out of the dating process with her, then by all means, move on. But if you’re getting something out of it, and that will depend on what it is you’re looking for — sex only, a monogamous romantic relationship, fun for now, etc. — gauge the progress of the dating process and use your result to make a decision about staying or going. 😉

    And if you’re just looking for sex, or if you’re looking for romance, but wondering how to make a move to advance the relationship sexually, then I’m going to assume you haven’t actually made a move to progress the relationship, sexually, because you’re afraid of rejection and/or you’re not getting the cues from her she’s that interested. Sometimes men write me about being friend-zoned and they find themselves stuck in that zone because they don’t make a move to get out of it. Usually, fear of rejection is the reason. Consider that that’s why you’re not making a move to dial up the heat in this relationship. 😎

    As for your fear of turning into a sugar daddy who spends money on dating someone who isn’t into you, that’s a real concern of many men, and it’s valid, but that’s why you have to decide, based on the dates, if she’s someone worth pursuing. And again, that’s all based on your knowing what it is you want from her.

    I hope that helps! 😀

    [b]Everyone likes to be liked! If the advice you found on AskApril.com was helpful “like” us on FB — and tell a friend!
    [url][/url]

    And… you can follow my interviews and advice in the press on Twitter [i]@AskAprilcom[/i][/b]

    #26598
    WickedTrombone
    Member #228,695

    Thanks for all the advice thus far April. I’ll definitely give the book a look!

    I apologize for flooding your board with questions of my own but I don’t have many others to turn to with experience in regards to stuff like this.

    Is it normal to have minimal communication between eachother between dates? My logical mind tells me if you’re interested in someone, you make a reasonable effort to chat with them whether over the phone or text between dates. You would respond or even initiate texts / phone calls if interested. She’s not responded to my last 3 texts or initiated anything back for the past few days since the date Tuesday, but has time to update her FB status. I know it’s good that she has continued to accept and meet me on dates on my terms, but it’s a little bothersome there hasn’t been as much communication inbetween as I would have liked. In person, she has no problem kissing me, or holding my hand in public. I guess you could say I’m somewhat of an active texter and to see she isn’t is a little discouraging. Am I reading too much into this lack of communication on her part?

    Is this a sign of disinterest? Is she on the fence? Does she not want to rush things? Plenty of things running through my mind after 5 dates.

    Thanks again for any response April!

    #23423
    Ask April Masini
    Keymaster

    A lot of times people project the problem they’re having in their real life onto me, and that’s what it seems you’re doing here. You came here with a single question, but when I answered it, you came up with a different question, and when I answered that, you came up with something else. 😳 I don’t think there’s an end to this. It really sounds like you are making excuses for yourself and procrastinating from doing what’s required to date better — because you don’t want to. If you keep asking questions but not doing the work or taking the advice, I can’t help you any more. You have to take action in your own life if you want to see changes. I’ve given you a lot of advice here, and I’ve suggested you buy a book that will help you — and I’m sorry, that’s all I can do for you here.

    If you’d like to become a private, playing client, let me know, and I can set up some individual coaching for you. 🙂

    [b]Everyone likes to be liked! If the advice you found on AskApril.com was helpful “like” us on FB — and tell a friend!
    [url][/url]

    And… you can follow my interviews and advice in the press on Twitter [i]@AskAprilcom[/i][/b]

    #48316
    Ethan Morales
    Member #382,560

    This guy’s entire problem isn’t the girl it’s his anxiety. He isn’t dating her… he’s dating the fear in his own head. He keeps overanalyzing everything: her texts, delays, tone, the fact she posted on Facebook. He’s chasing reassurance instead of building connection. That kind of thinking burns relationships before they even start.

    April was right he never actually asked her out clearly. Saying “I want to see you Wednesday” is not the same as:
    “Are you free Wednesday? Let’s do dinner at 7.” She responded, and he didn’t follow through. She gave him an opening, he dropped the ball. That’s why April kept repeating the same point he’s creating drama around a simple issue.

    The intimacy confusion? That was also a confidence problem. She did like him. She was physically affectionate, playful, and giving him green lights. When she said “too fast,” she wasn’t testing him sexually she was checking his emotional maturity. Instead of staying grounded, he spiraled into overthinking.

    Her inconsistent texting is NOT a red flag it’s her personality.She literally showed him:
    she ignores her phone
    her family complains she ignores her phone
    she responded when it mattered (dates)
    she showed up even when sick
    She is showing interest through actions, not texting frequency. He’s misreading everything because he needs constant validation.

    The huge issue? He’s trying to control the pace with anxiety instead of leadership. He keeps asking April:
    “What do I do next? What pace is right? What if I look needy?”
    That’s insecurity talking. When a guy moves from curiosity → fear, the girl feels the shift. She starts pulling back because he’s not matching her vibe anymore.

    April ended bluntly for a reason.
    She wasn’t annoyed she saw the pattern:
    He’s not taking action.
    He’s asking questions to avoid doing anything scary.
    When someone keeps looping the same anxiety, no amount of advice fixes it.
    He needed confidence coaching, not dating tips.

    This girl liked him, and he had every opportunity.
    What sabotaged things wasn’t her behavior
    it was his overthinking and fear-driven approach.
    If he relaxed, trusted himself, and led clearly, this relationship would’ve unfolded naturally.

    #49286
    Tara
    Member #382,680

    She’s losing interest, and you’re too busy overanalysing breadcrumbs to see it. If a woman wants you, she doesn’t vanish for 48 hours after grinding on you in bed. She doesn’t send a limp “Hey!” eight hours after your voicemail. She doesn’t go silent every time you show initiative. She’s not being mysterious. She’s being inconsistent because she doesn’t care enough to be consistent.

    That night in bed wasn’t some psychological exam; it was the heat of the moment, followed by regret, hesitation, or second thoughts. You didn’t pass or fail anything. She just realised she wasn’t ready to go further or wasn’t sure about you, and now she’s pulling back while you obsess over imaginary signals.
    Your “I’ll make her wait like she makes me wait” strategy is pathetic. You’re trying to win a game she’s not even playing. She’s not sitting there tracking your reply, Tim, she’s just not invested.

    Stop chasing. Stop decoding every word. Stop acting like a man trying to decode the Rosetta Stone of a woman who’s barely participating. Match her energy: low and distant. If she doesn’t step up, let her go. The only mind game happening here is the one you’re playing on yourself by pretending her inconsistency is romantic tension instead of disinterest.

    #49564
    Sally
    Member #382,674

    When someone comes on strong one minute and goes quiet the next… it messes with your head. But honestly? This doesn’t feel like a test. It feels like a girl who doesn’t really know what she wants yet, so she keeps dipping in and out.

    That night in bed that was her getting caught up in the moment, then freaking herself out. Not you. And the slow replies? That’s someone who likes the attention but isn’t steady enough to carry the rest of it.

    You don’t need to play games back. Just match her energy. If she shows up, you show up. If she drifts, let her. That’ll tell you more than any guessing ever will.
    You deserve someone who doesn’t make you wonder what page they’re on.

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 16 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Comments are closed.