[Ethan Morales]

The pattern here is very clear. She’s blocked you, limited contact, and consistently communicated that she doesn’t want to see you right now. That’s her boundary, and it’s consistent. No amount of text, call, or gift-giving is going to change that in the short term. Respecting that boundary isn’t being cold or uncaring it’s recognizing reality.

The reasons she’s given are legitimate she’s dealing with serious life stressors: an eating disorder, job loss, moving home, and emotional instability. None of these make her “unworthy” of love, but they do make her unavailable for a relationship that requires attention, communication, and emotional reciprocity. Trying to force interaction now risks pushing her further away or creating resentment on both sides.

The idea of waiting to call for two weeks is sound in principle, but even the birthday situation isn’t a strong enough reason to reach out if she’s already been clear. Sending a gift or acknowledging her birthday could be perceived as pressure, especially since she’s in a vulnerable state. Right now, your focus should be on your emotional boundaries, not bending over backward to maintain a connection that isn’t reciprocated.

Her need for “time to miss you” is tricky. You can’t manufacture that. Waiting while hoping she suddenly realizes she wants you isn’t practical it’s speculative and emotionally draining. The key here is accepting that she’s unavailable and using that time to focus on yourself, your own goals, and other potential relationships with people who are ready and able to engage fully.

The text/email blocking and cutting off contact isn’t manipulative; it’s protective for her and for you. Being frustrated or upset is natural, but repeatedly trying to reach her sends the message that your boundaries are weak. Strength comes from recognizing when to step back, even when it hurts.

April’s advice is spot-on. You’re chasing someone who is not currently available, and continuing to push will only prolong frustration and emotional strain. The healthiest choice is to step back completely, allow her to focus on herself, and redirect your energy toward relationships that are mutually engaging and healthy. Waiting for her “recovery” isn’t a realistic strategy focus on building your own life while she works on hers. let go, respect her space, and protect your own emotional well-being. That’s the only practical path forward.

[Tara]

She’s done. She checked out weeks ago, and you’re still clinging to crumbs because you can’t accept the reality she’s already spelled out for you. Blocking you on Facebook, refusing to see you, dodging calls, giving non-answers, and finally saying she doesn’t want to see you anymore, that isn’t a woman on the fence. That’s a woman trying to leave without setting off your emotional alarm system.

You’re inventing excuses to avoid the obvious. “She didn’t miss me because I always texted back.” No. She didn’t miss you because she doesn’t want the relationship anymore. You’re spinning theories to protect your ego while she quietly exits the building.

And the “I’m getting rid of texting” lie? That wasn’t a strategy; it was desperation. You’re trying to manipulate her into chasing you because you can’t handle the fact that she’s already gone. She’s not confused by your devotion; she’s uncomfortable with your inability to let go. Every voicemail you left pushed her further away. And yes, the frustrated message accusing her of being on a date? That sealed it. You went from “supportive guy” to “clingy obligation” in one voicemail.

Your four-month anniversary doesn’t matter to her. If she wanted to see you, she would’ve. She didn’t. And she won’t. Same with her birthday, she told you a week ago you could see her because she didn’t want conflict. But her silence since then tells you the truth: she doesn’t want the gift, the celebration, or the contact. She wants distance. You’re treating her birthday like a magic loophole that will resurrect the relationship. It won’t.

Stop asking how long you should wait to contact her. She already answered that for you: don’t. She doesn’t want texts, calls, gifts, explanations, or anniversaries. She wants space, not space so she “misses you,” but space because the relationship is over and she doesn’t have the energy to manage your reactions on top of her personal issues.

[Sally]

I know it’s hard to hear this, but she’s already stepped out of the relationship. Not because you weren’t good to her, but because she’s drowning in her own stuff and can’t carry a boyfriend on top of it. When someone says they don’t want to see you, don’t miss you, don’t feel worthwhile… they’re telling the truth of where they are.
And calling her twice, especially the frustrated voicemail that probably pushed her further away. Not out of anger, just overwhelm.

Right now, she needs space more than she needs anything from you. And you need some peace, too. Stop chasing. Don’t call for the birthday. Keep the necklace for now. Let the silence settle.

If she ever wants to come back, she’ll reach out clearly. But holding on this tight is only breaking your heart in slow motion.
Give both of you room to breathe.

[Natalie Noah]

Two people caught in emotional chaos rather than a healthy relationship. The girl he’s dating is clearly not available. she has major personal issues, including stress, counseling needs, and self-esteem struggles. She has communicated that she needs space and time to focus on herself, yet Rusty continues to chase her, seeking reassurance and validation. This cycle of blocking, unblocking, texting, and calling is not love; it’s emotional turbulence, and it’s exhausting for both parties.

Anxiety and obsessive behavior make the situation worse. His constant need for confirmation, fear of rejection, and impulsive actions like leaving frustrated voicemails or demanding answers only push the girl further away. Even though he genuinely cares for her, the way he expresses that care is coming from fear and insecurity rather than calm confidence. This dynamic creates a push-pull pattern that neither person can thrive in emotionally.

The core issue here isn’t just about whether she will forgive or come back to him. It’s about Rusty recognizing his own emotional patterns and taking responsibility for his mental and emotional well-being. He is chasing someone who is unavailable and using energy trying to fix or control something he cannot. The healthy step is to stop chasing, focus on self-healing, and learn to tolerate uncertainty without acting impulsively. Only then can he be ready for a stable, fulfilling relationship.

The lesson Noah would gently emphasize is this: love isn’t about intensity or fear-driven attachment. Love is mutual, consistent, and nurturing. Rusty needs to let go of the relationship not because he doesn’t care, but because caring in this way is hurting him. Giving himself space, seeking counseling, and building self-respect will prepare him for someone who truly wants to be with him someone who will meet him with consistency and emotional availability, instead of chaos and confusion.

[Author]

Posts