"April Masini answers questions no one else can and tells you the truth that no one else will."

Is it over?

Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
[hfe_template id="51444"]
  • Member
    Posts
  • #3469
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    ok so my girlfriend and I of two and a half years broke up last month. We broke up because she belived i lied to her about another girl while i was away in college. I tried to win her back by coming over to her house and talking. she had my stuff in her hands and told me to leave. furious i left and threw the chain she gave me for christmas on her lawn. i tried to aplogize but it did not work. i havent talked to her in a month almost. i thought if i gave her some space she would calm down and we could talk civily again. however i learned that she has a new boyfriend and from what i heard from other mutual friends he is the direct opposite of me. i was never clingy and he is. he is unemployed. I work two jobs. He doesnt go to school. I am in college and in the rotc program at my school. my question is, is he a rebound fling or is she seriously done with me? i wuld like to get back with her. please keep answers honest and truthful. shes 16 and i am 18 by the way. her new bf is 19. also i have learned they have started saying i love you after only two weeks of knowing each other

    #17230

    It sounds like a fling to me and here’s the reason why: She was very, very hurt by what she thought you did and in order to feel safe again, she replaced you with someone who is your opposite. By choosing someone who is your opposite, she rationalized that he would never hurt her in the way that you did (or what she thought you did) because he is so different. That the relationship appears to be moving very quickly is another sign that she’s trying to get back what she had with you from this other guy — a long term relationship.

    So, yes, I think it’s a fling — however, that doesn’t mean that the two of you aren’t over. 😳 Giving her too much space after your blow up where you were both reactive, may not have done what you figured it would. Your break up was based on a miscommunication and it sounds like she also misconstrued your giving her space as not caring and moving on, yourself.

    My suggestion is that you write her a letter explaining your feelings and that you’d like to see her again. You’re going to have to win her back — it won’t be as easy as walking into a room and claiming what’s yours since she’s dating someone else now.

    I hope that helps. Let me know how things go, and I hope you’ll follow me @AskAprilcom (no dot!) on Twitter and on Facebook at this link: [url][/url].

    #17479
    london7432
    Member #33,588

    I wrote her a letter a week ago. it talks of me apologizing and thats it. I didn’t mention my love for her. other dating sites told me to do this. and if shes in a rebound, which you clearly stated she is, that I should wait it out. But I honestly want to know what i your opinion, should I wait it out or should I go for the kill now?

    #17021

    I’m not exactly sure what you consider to be “going for the kill”. I think you mean you want to ask her out now instead of waiting. That’s fine. It will give you some clarity.

    Let me know how it goes — and please follow me @AskAprilcom on Twitter as well as on Facebook at this link: [url][/url]. 🙂

Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Comments are closed.